Why is this study important?
- Lack of randomized comparison between transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR or TAVI) and surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) in younger, low-risk patients, including those with both tricuspid and bicuspid aortic stenosis (AS).
- A large population of young, low-risk patients are currently treated with TAVI despite insufficient evidence supporting this approach.
What question was this study supposed to answer?
- What are the clinical outcomes in low-risk and young (≤ 75yrs) AS patients treated with TAVR and SAVR, including those with both tricuspid and bicuspid AS?
- Prior studies comparing low-risk patients such as PARTNER 3, Evolut Low risk, and NOTION trials demonstrated similar or lower mortality and stroke with TAVR when compared to SAVR. However, a significant portion of the patients in the trial were >75yrs old, and bicuspid AS patients were excluded.
What did the study show?
- 370 patients were randomized to TAVR (n=187) and SAVR (n=183),
- Primary endpoint: composite of death, stroke, or rehospitalization at one year was similar between TAVR and SAVR groups (10.2 % Vs. 7.1%; Hazard ratio, 1.4 [95% CI, 0.7-2.9]).
- Death and disabling stroke were similar between the TAVR and SAVR groups at one year (3.2% vs 1.6%, Hazard ratio, 2.0 [95% CI, 0.5-7.8]).
- TAVR was associated with higher non-disabling stroke and moderate or greater paravalvular regurgitation. However, the difference was contributed by the higher rate of events in bicuspid TAVR cohort.
- TAVR had higher new permanent pacemaker implantation, but lower new onset atrial fibrillation and major bleeding compared to SAVR.
- TAVR cohort had more rapid improvement in dyspnea and quality of life compared to surgery.
Key Takeaways:
- There is clinical equipoise for TAVR Vs. SAVR in the overall study cohort of low-risk, young patients (≤75yrs old) concerning death, stroke, or rehospitalization at one year.
- A larger trial specifically focusing on outcomes in young patients with bicuspid AS may be beneficial to better assess issues specific to this population.
Other Specialist Resources for Congenital Heart Disease
Including recently published studies, coverage of late-breaking science, updates from clinical trials and registries, and complex case presentations.
Clinical Interest Article
Dramatic Dose Reduction in Three-Dimensional Rotational Angiography After Implementation of a Simple Dose Reduction Protocol
Originally published in August 2018.
Clinical Interest Article
Balloon Angioplasty and Stenting for Unilateral Branch Pulmonary Artery Stenosis Improve Exertional Performance
The authors sought to determine whether intervention for unilateral pulmonary artery stenosis improved exercise capacity, abn...
Clinical Interest Article
Relation of Aortic Valve Morphologic Characteristics to Aortic Valve Insufficiency and Residual Stenosis in Children with Congenital Aortic Stenosis Undergoing Balloon Valvuloplasty
Published December 31st 2015.
Clinical Interest Article
Single-Barrel, Double-Barrel, and Fenestrated Endografts to Facilitate Transcatheter Pulmonary Valve Replacement in Large RVOT
The authors report on a unique series of eight patients with severe pulmonary insufficiency and RVOTs too large for conventio...
Integrated Search Topics